Etsy vs Shopify for Beginners in 2026: The Real $100-Sale Math + Which to Start With
Earnrove may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Every “Etsy vs Shopify” guide says one is cheaper. Almost none shows the actual math on a single sale — and that number decides which platform makes sense for a beginner. A $100 order costs about $9.95 on Etsy and about $3.20 on Shopify. That gap looks like an easy Shopify win until you remember the $29–$39 a month Shopify charges, selling or not.
I’ve run the numbers both ways, and neither platform wins for everyone. Etsy wins while you’re small. Shopify wins once you’re selling real volume. This guide works out where that line sits, what each platform quietly takes, and the order to start in if you want both.
The $100-sale test: where the whole decision starts
Forget the feature lists. Take one $100 sale and watch what each platform keeps.
| Line | Etsy | Shopify Basic |
|---|---|---|
| Listing fee | $0.20 | $0 |
| Transaction fee | $6.50 (6.5%) | $0 |
| Payment processing | $3.25 (3% + $0.25) | $3.20 (2.9% + $0.30) |
| Total taken from a $100 sale | $9.95 | $3.20 |
| Monthly plan cost | $0 (Etsy Plus is an optional $10/mo) | $29/mo billed annually, $39/mo billed monthly |
| You keep, before your costs | $90.05 | $96.80, minus the plan |
On one sale, Shopify keeps $6.75 more — $67.50 across ten $100 sales, more than double the $29 plan. So why doesn’t everyone start on Shopify? Because the plan is a fixed bill and your first months usually aren’t ten-sale months. Zero sales on Etsy costs you the $0.20 listing fee; zero sales on Shopify still costs $29–$39.
The full fee stack, side by side
The $100 test shows only the headline fees. Here’s everything else that can touch your money, from both platforms’ published 2026 fee schedules.
| Fee | Etsy | Shopify Basic |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly plan | Free to open; optional Etsy Plus $10/mo | $39/mo monthly, $29/mo billed annually |
| Listing fee | $0.20 per listing, renewed every 4 months or on each sale of a multi-quantity listing | None |
| Transaction fee | 6.5% of item price + shipping charged + gift wrap | None |
| Payment processing (US) | 3% + $0.25 per order | 2.9% + $0.30 per online card payment |
| Regulatory operating fee (US) | About 0.35%, varies by state | None |
| Offsite Ads | 12–15% on sales driven by Etsy’s ads; mandatory once your shop passes $10,000 in trailing-12-month sales (12% for life after $10k, 15% below) | None — you run your own ads |
| Third-party gateway surcharge | Not applicable | +2% if you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments |
| One-time setup fee | $15–$29, regional — not charged everywhere | None |
| Free trial | None needed — no monthly bill | 3-day free trial, then $1/mo for 3 months on select plans |
Two things in that table catch beginners out. First, Etsy’s 6.5% applies to the shipping you charge, not just the item price. Second, Shopify’s $5 Starter plan shows up in some older guides, but it’s closed to new stores — Basic at $29–$39 a month is the real entry point.
Run your own numbers with our Etsy True Profit Calculator — it covers this whole stack, including the regulatory fee — or read our guide to how to calculate Etsy fees in 2026 for more examples.
The breakeven month: when Shopify starts winning
At what monthly sales level does Shopify’s lower per-sale cut beat its monthly bill? Assume $100 orders, no Offsite Ads, and no paid apps for now.
| Monthly sales | Etsy fees (~9.95%) | Shopify ($29 plan + 3.2%) | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| $300 (3 orders) | $29.85 | $38.60 | Etsy, by about $9 |
| $800 (8 orders) | $79.60 | $54.60 | Shopify, by $25 |
| $1,500 (15 orders) | $149.25 | $77.00 | Shopify, by $72 |
| $3,000 (30 orders) | $298.50 | $125.00 | Shopify, by $173 |
On fees alone, the crossover lands around $430–$580 a month in sales, depending on the plan. But that table is the floor: a working Shopify store rarely costs just the plan — apps, a paid theme, and email tools add up — while an Etsy seller can also get hit with listing renewals and Offsite Ads. That’s why most guides put the real-world switch point around $1,100–$1,500 a month. Below that, Etsy usually wins; above it, Shopify pulls away fast, and by $3,000 a month the gap is nearly $175 in Shopify’s favor.
One extra check for digital sellers: on a $10 download, Etsy’s flat fees take about $1.40 (14%) versus $0.59 on Shopify — and one guide worked out that around 36 sales of $10 downloads a month is enough for Basic to win on fees alone. Cheap digital products cross the line much earlier than $100 handmade goods.
The 60-second decision tree
1. Do you already have an audience?
If you have a TikTok following, a Pinterest account that drives clicks, or even a small email list, Shopify is on the table — you can send those people to your own store. Starting from zero, Etsy wins by a mile: its roughly 86.5 million active buyers (per Etsy’s latest annual filing) are already searching for what you sell.
2. What are you selling?
Etsy only allows handmade items, vintage goods (20+ years old), and craft supplies. If your product fits that box, Etsy is built for you. Reselling manufactured goods or dropshipping? Shopify is the only real choice of the two.
3. How much can you spend before your first sale?
Etsy costs $15–$29 to open where the setup fee applies, plus $0.20 per listing — ten listings for under $35 total. Shopify costs $1 a month for three months after the trial on select plans, then $29–$39 a month, selling or not. If your budget is close to zero, that’s Etsy.
4. Do you want a brand or a stall?
On Etsy, you’re a seller inside Etsy’s brand: same-looking shops, Etsy controls the search ranking, and you never get your customers’ email addresses. On Shopify, the store is yours — domain, design, customer list, repeat buyers. If the long-term goal is a brand people remember by name, Shopify is where that lives. If the goal is your first sales this month, Etsy gets you there faster.
What Etsy gives you that Shopify can’t — and what it takes away
Etsy’s real product isn’t the shop builder. It’s the traffic. Around 86.5 million active buyers browse Etsy looking for handmade and vintage things, and a new seller can get views in week one without spending a cent on ads. No $29 Shopify plan can buy you that.
The price of that traffic is control. Etsy decides where you rank and can change the rules without asking. You can’t email buyers after a sale — Etsy keeps their contact details — and your shop design is a template with your photos in it. Once your trailing-12-month sales pass $10,000, Offsite Ads become mandatory: Etsy can spend its ad money to bring you a sale and take 12% of it, with no opt-out. And a shop that lives on one platform lives with that platform’s suspension risk.
What Shopify gives you that Etsy can’t — and what it costs
Shopify gives you ownership: your store, checkout, customer emails, discount codes, blog, and analytics — and no marketplace ranking that can change overnight. You set the prices, you keep the customer relationship, and repeat buyers come back to you, not to a marketplace that also shows them your competitors.
What it costs is traffic. Shopify sends you nobody — every visitor comes from something you did: Pinterest pins, TikTok videos, Google search, paid ads, an email list you built yourself. That takes months, and it’s why most beginners who start on Shopify end up staring at a beautiful store with three visitors a day. Our full breakdown of Shopify fees in 2026 covers the plan tiers and the 2% third-party gateway trap.
The both-platforms playbook: start on Etsy, add Shopify later
You don’t have to choose forever. The sellers who do best usually run both, in this order.
Phase 1 — Etsy first (months 1–6). List your best 10–20 products and let Etsy’s search bring your first sales and reviews. Use this phase to learn which products actually sell and what your real margins are — the Etsy True Profit Calculator will tell you what you keep on each order.
Phase 2 — add Shopify when sales pass ~$1,000 a month. List your proven winners there and point social media and repeat buyers to your own store, where you keep more of each sale. Keep the Etsy shop running — it’s still your discovery channel, and some buyers will only ever shop on Etsy.
Phase 3 — let each platform do its job. Etsy finds new customers; Shopify keeps them. Test new products on Etsy, push proven winners on Shopify, and price consistently across both — a product that earns $90 on Etsy earns about $97 on Shopify before the plan, so don’t undercut your own store.
One caution: don’t just copy listings between platforms without checking the rules. Etsy has its own policies on what’s allowed, and a Shopify store still needs proper descriptions, shipping settings, and tax setup. Treat them as two shops, not one shop pasted twice.
Your first-month budget on each
| Cost | Etsy | Shopify Basic |
|---|---|---|
| Setup / opening | $15–$29 one-time (regional) | $0 |
| First 10 listings | $2.00 | $0 |
| First month’s plan | $0 (Plus optional, $10/mo) | $1/mo for 3 months after the 3-day trial, on select plans |
| Month-one total | Roughly $17–$31 | Roughly $1 |
| Month-four cost | $0 + per-sale fees | $29/mo billed annually or $39/mo billed monthly |
Shopify looks cheaper in month one because of the $1 trial pricing, but that ends after three months and the $29–$39 bill starts even in a month with zero sales. Etsy costs more to open, but nothing when you’re not selling. Budget for month four, not month one.
Ready to open the Etsy side? Our step-by-step guide to how to open an Etsy shop in 2026 covers setup, the regional fee, and your first listings.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better for beginners, Shopify or Etsy?
For most beginners, Etsy: almost nothing to open, buyers from day one, you only pay when you sell. Shopify is better once you have your own traffic or you’re selling around $1,100–$1,500 a month — roughly where its lower per-sale fees outweigh the monthly plan.
Is Shopify or Etsy cheaper for beginners?
Etsy is cheaper while you’re small: about $9.95 in fees on a $100 sale, nothing when you don’t sell. Shopify is cheaper per sale ($3.20 on $100) but adds $29–$39 a month, so it only wins once your sales cover the plan.
Can you sell on both Etsy and Shopify at the same time?
Yes. The usual play is Etsy first for discovery, then add Shopify once sales pass roughly $1,000 a month — Etsy keeps finding new customers while Shopify keeps more margin on repeat buyers.
Does Etsy or Shopify take a bigger cut of each sale?
Etsy takes the bigger cut per sale — about $9.95 on a $100 order versus about $3.20 on Shopify Basic. But Shopify also charges a $29–$39 monthly plan, so Etsy’s total cost stays lower until your sales pass the breakeven point.
Do I need a website if I sell on Etsy?
No — your Etsy shop is your storefront: Etsy hosts it, handles checkout, and brings the traffic. A website becomes worth having when you want your own brand, customer list, and better margins, usually when you add Shopify later.
Is it worth paying for Shopify when you’re just starting out?
Usually not at first. The $1-for-3-months trial pricing makes it cheap to try, but after that it’s $29–$39 a month even with zero sales. Start on Etsy, prove the product sells, and move to Shopify when monthly sales reach around $1,100–$1,500 — where the lower fees cover the plan.
Can I move my Etsy shop to Shopify later?
Yes — export your Etsy listings and import them into Shopify, and plenty of sellers run both shops at once rather than closing Etsy. Your Etsy reviews and search ranking don’t transfer, so keep the Etsy shop open for discovery while you build the Shopify store’s own traffic.
Is selling on Etsy worth it in 2026?
For handmade, vintage, and craft-supply sellers, yes — around 86.5 million active buyers is a real audience, and the fee stack is manageable if you price with it in mind. It stops being worth it when your volume passes the breakeven point and Etsy’s per-sale cut costs more than a Shopify plan — the moment to add your own store.
The bottom line
Start on Etsy — the cheapest way to find out if anyone wants what you make, and its buyers are already there. When monthly sales start pushing past $1,000–$1,500, open a Shopify store for your proven winners and repeat customers. Etsy finds them; Shopify keeps them. That’s not a compromise — it’s the order most sellers who make real money followed.
All figures are planning estimates from Etsy and Shopify’s published 2026 fee schedules — Etsy fees verified against Etsy’s Fees & Payments Policy, Shopify pricing against its own pricing page, and the buyer figure from Etsy’s latest annual filing. Fees change and the setup fee varies by region, so check both sites before you commit. Estimate only, not tax or financial advice.